Johnson & Goldstein Organ Donation Defaults: Opt-In vs. Opt-Out
Edited by Paweł Raja, PhD · Published · Updated
In Johnson and Goldstein's (2003) online experiment with 161 respondents, 42% agreed to be organ donors when the default was not to donate (opt-in), compared with 82% when donation was the default (opt-out) and 79% when they had to choose with no default.
Respondents agreeing to be organ donors (online experiment) · Online experiment
Opt-in default: 42% → Opt-out default: 82% (+40.0 pts, +95% relative)
Neutral condition (forced choice, no default): 79%. This is stated willingness in a hypothetical scenario, not actual registrations or donations.
Study details
- Study design
- Online experiment
- Problem
- Most people say they approve of organ donation, but far fewer register. Johnson and Goldstein cite a US poll in which 85% of Americans approved of donation but only 28% had given permission by signing a donor card. More than 45,000 people in the United States had died since 1995 while waiting for a suitable organ.
- Intervention
- In an online experiment, respondents imagined they had just moved to a new state and were asked whether they would be donors. In the opt-in version, the default was not being a donor. In the opt-out version, the default was being a donor. In the neutral version, they had to choose with no default. Changing status took one mouse click, which largely rules out effort as the explanation.
- Outcome
- Respondents agreeing to be organ donors (online experiment): 42% (Opt-in default) → 82% (Opt-out default); +40.0 pts, +95% relative
- Sample
- 161 online respondents; cross-country consent data for European countries
- Key takeaway
- The default roughly doubled stated willingness to donate, and an opt-out default did about as well as forcing an active choice. Across Europe, effective consent under presumed-consent laws was nearly 60 percentage points higher than under explicit-consent laws. Actual donation rates differed far less, by about 16%.
- Biases involved
- Default EffectStatus Quo Bias
- Source
- Johnson, E. J., & Goldstein, D. (2003). Do defaults save lives? Science, 302(5649), 1338-1339. doi:10.1126/science.1091721 ↗ full text (PDF)Numbers checked against: p. 1338 (online-experiment and country figures); p. 1339 (donation-rate regression)
What the study did
This two-page Policy Forum in Science combines three kinds of evidence. The first is the online experiment above. Donation rates were about twice as high under opt-out as under opt-in. The opt-out condition did not differ significantly from the neutral, no-default condition; only the opt-in condition, then the norm in the United States, was significantly lower.
The second compares effective consent rates across European countries: the share who had opted in where consent is explicit, or the share who had not opted out where consent is presumed. In the explicit-consent countries shown, the rates ranged from 4.25% (Denmark) and 12% (Germany) to 17.17% (United Kingdom) and 27.5% (Netherlands). In the presumed-consent countries, they ranged from 85.9% (Sweden) to 99.98% (Austria). The two groups did not overlap, and nearly 60 percentage points separated them.
The third asks whether consent turns into donations. Registration is not donation: families can object, doctors may hesitate to rely on presumed consent, and infrastructure differs. The authors regressed actual cadaveric donation rates for 1991-2001 on the default, controlling for transplant infrastructure, education and religion. Presumed consent was associated with a 16.3% increase in donation, from 14.1 to 16.4 donors per million people. That is a real difference, but much smaller than the gap in registration.
The authors give three reasons a default matters. People may read it as the policymaker's recommendation. Accepting it takes no effort, while an active decision about donation can be unpleasant. And moving away from it can feel like a loss. They also note that the Netherlands' 1998 national donor registry, launched with an education campaign and a mailing of more than 12 million letters, did not change the effective consent rate.
Limitations and caveats
- The experiment measured stated willingness in a hypothetical online scenario with 161 respondents, not real registrations.
- The cross-country comparison is observational. Countries that adopt presumed consent may differ in other ways, which is why the authors add controls in the donation-rate regression.
- Higher consent did not bring a matching rise in donations: about 16% more donors per million, against a consent gap of nearly 60 percentage points. Opt-out laws change who is registered more than they change the whole donation pipeline.
- Defaults can misclassify people in both directions: willing donors who never register, and people registered against their wishes. The authors flag this trade-off as an ethical question for policymakers.
Cite this page
Raja, P. (Ed.). (2026, 8 Oct 2026). Johnson & Goldstein Organ Donation Defaults: Opt-In vs. Opt-Out. Behavioral Economics Lab. https://www.behavioraleconomicslab.com/findings/organ-donation-defaults
Primary source: Johnson, E. J., & Goldstein, D. (2003). Do defaults save lives? Science, 302(5649), 1338-1339.