Correlation Neglect
Edited by Paweł Raja, PhD · Published
Definition
Correlation Neglect is the cognitive failure to account for the duplication of information from correlated sources, leading individuals to treat redundant messages as independent confirmation.
- Also known as:
- Persuasion bias
- Category:
- Social Influence
- Impact:
- High
- Landmark study:
- Enke & Zimmermann (2019)
- Evidence here:
- 1 field finding, 6 cited studies
Why it happens: the psychology of correlation neglect
When several sources share the same underlying information, hearing all of them should not be more convincing than hearing one. Correlation neglect is the failure to account for that overlap: people treat echoed signals as independent evidence and become too confident.
DeMarzo, Vayanos and Zwiebel (2003) modeled this as 'persuasion bias' in social networks. If people do not adjust for repetition, well-connected voices whose views are repeated by many others gain outsized influence.
Enke and Zimmermann (2019) tested it directly. Participants received signals, some of which were clearly copies of the same underlying information, and many still updated as if each were independent. Beliefs became too extreme, and the bias persisted with higher stakes, though it shrank when the correlation structure was made very simple.
Ortoleva and Snowberg (2015) linked the same failure to political overconfidence: people who neglect correlation among the news they consume tend to hold more extreme and more confident views.
Correlation Neglect examples
An investor reads three separate newsletters recommending a stock, not realizing all three newsletters are summarizing the exact same press release, and becomes overly confident.
- Several analysts echoing one original report can feel like a broad consensus rather than a single source.
- Combining an expert's judgment with an AI that used the same data double-counts the shared signal.
How to avoid correlation neglect
- Trace claims to their origin. Before counting several reports as several pieces of evidence, check whether they all cite the same press release, study or person.
- Count independent sources, not mentions. Three articles quoting one analyst are one data point.
- Diversify where your information comes from, especially on contested topics where networks tend to echo each other.
How to design for it (nudge strategy)
Explicitly trace and group source references in data displays (e.g., '3 news outlets citing 1 primary source') to prevent users from forming exaggerated confidence based on redundant inputs.
Ethical use: design for choices people would endorse on reflection — a nudge, not sludge. Be transparent and keep opting out easy.
The evidence (1)
- AI Assistance in Radiology: Why AI Predictions Did Not Improve Radiologists' Accuracy
Healthcare · Average deviation from the diagnostic standard (0-100 probability points; lower is better): X-ray only (control mean) 22.6 → With AI predictions 22.9 (+0.3 pts; Randomized experiment; 227 radiologists; 324 patient cases; 41,920 observations)
Key studies
Experimental participants double-counted correlated signals, leading to overly extreme beliefs.
Enke, B., & Zimmermann, F. (2019). Correlation neglect in belief formation. Review of Economic Studies, 86(1), 313–332. DOI →
Modeled how failing to adjust for repeated information gives well-connected sources excess influence.
DeMarzo, P. M., Vayanos, D., & Zwiebel, J. (2003). Persuasion bias, social influence, and unidimensional opinions. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 118(3), 909–968. DOI →
Showed how people who treat others' actions as independent information can herd on wrong conclusions.
Eyster, E., & Rabin, M. (2010). Naïve herding in rich-information settings. American Economic Journal: Microeconomics, 2(4), 221–243. DOI →
Linked correlation neglect to overconfidence and ideological extremeness in voters.
Ortoleva, P., & Snowberg, E. (2015). Overconfidence in political behavior. American Economic Review, 105(2), 504–535. DOI →
Key research
- Correlation Neglect in Belief FormationBenjamin Enke, Florian Zimmermann · The Review of Economic Studies (2019)
- Combining Human Expertise with Artificial Intelligence: Experimental Evidence from RadiologyNikhil Agarwal, Alex Moehring, Pranav Rajpurkar, Tobias Salz · NBER Working Paper Series (2023)
Related biases
Correlation Neglect: frequently asked questions
What is correlation neglect?
Correlation neglect is treating information from related sources as if it were independent, so the same underlying signal gets counted several times and beliefs become overconfident.
What is an example of correlation neglect?
Feeling sure about a stock because three newsletters recommend it, without noticing they all summarize the same company announcement.
How is correlation neglect related to echo chambers?
In echo chambers, the same view is repeated by many connected people. If listeners do not discount for that repetition, the view seems better supported than it is — the mechanism DeMarzo, Vayanos and Zwiebel called persuasion bias.
Cite this page
Raja, P. (Ed.). (2026, 8 Oct 2026). Correlation Neglect. Behavioral Economics Lab. https://www.behavioraleconomicslab.com/biases/correlation-neglect